Every couple of days I head over to Tumblr to check out my dashboard, which normally overflows with — no surprise to frequent readers of this blog — info about and images of Gene Kelly, Colin Firth, Jon Stewart, and Shakespeare. But hey, sometimes I also wake up to pics of Bogie and Bacall, Cary Grant, Judy Garland, Hugh Laurie, Kenneth Branagh, Karl Pilkington, and the guys from Men of a Certain Age. So there.
While still photographs like this one of Colin Firth showering in coffee — sure, I’ll give you a minute — mostly decorate my Tumblr dash, animated gifs are becoming equally as prominent. And why not? With free, web-based create-your-own-animated-GIF programs like Gickr.com and Picasion as well as downloadable ones like GIF QuickMaker (for Macs) and Ulead GIF Animator (Windows), virtually any social network user may try her hand at creating these little moving pictures.
For those unfamiliar with the term, an animated gif is a “single graphic file that contains a series of images which are displayed sequentially to give the illusion of movement” (Motive Glossary). Basically, it’s the same thing that initiated the movies. Sure it is. Think back to your first cinema history course, when you learned about the zoetrope, that popular Victorian-era device that allowed users to view static pictures of a juggler or a bird as though he was moving. Gather ’round the kids, spin the wheel, look through the slats, and watch that dove fly, fly away.
Or maybe you recall Eadweard Muybridge’s experiment? You know the one: in which a grisly looking photographer rustled up a horse, some trip wires, large cameras, and a racetrack and ultimately put to rest the age-old question, “Is there ever a time when all four feet of a galloping horse are off the ground?” (The answer: yes!) But more importantly, Muybridge put his still images (below, left) on a disc and then ran them through a zoopraxiscope to give them the impression of motion (below, right). This little experiment and device, you’ll remember from class, ultimately inspired Thomas Edison and his buddy W.K.L. Dickson to create the kinetoscope, also known as our first commercial film exhibition system.
Finally, to those who never took a film course: first, shame on you! Second, think back to third grade when you doodled stick-figures on the bottom right-hand corner of your notebook and then, when the teacher turned to scribble on the chalkboard, you flipped the pages to make those little people “move.” The animated gif: yeah, practically the same thing. TRIVIA: Like the zoetrope, these little flip or flick books also appeared during the late nineteenth century, originally called kineographs. You may watch one in action here.
In addition to their obvious purpose — to make still pictures move — animated gifs function like early cinema in several ways. First, as Lisa Nakamura points out in Digitizing Race: Visual Cultures on the Internet, both attempt to reproduce an experience, not a story. Indeed, spectators of early cinema or the “cinema of attractions” (1895-1907) were so enamored by the moving images before them that a conventional narrative with a beginning, middle, and end were unnecessary. As well, both early cinema and animated gifs are silent, exhibited in relatively private settings (e.g., kinetoscope, laptop/phone screen), and generally considered wastes of time. Finally, like many of the first cinematic peep shows, animated gifs loop until they’re clicked off (63-66).
So why this newfound interest in creating, posting, and sharing animated gifs on social networking sites? After all, these little moving pictures have been around since the early 1990s (e.g., AOL IM icons, that creepy dancing baby from Ally McBeal). From my research, the most frequent answer to this question — and often the only answer given since no one seems to know why we’re circulating them — is that they’re fun. Yes, at the basest level, for many people, animated gifs are simply fun, entertaining to look at. They can make us giggle, swoon, shudder, and laugh; they can remind us of a particular shot or scene from one of our favorite films or TV shows; they can capture a specific moment in time and loop it for all eternity, all in the name of fun. Here are some of animated gifs I’ve collected over the past year. I dare you to tell me they’re not fun.
Oh, to be that phone receiver.
Parks and Recreation‘s Ron Swanson, hyped up on Snake Juice.
Aside from entertainment (and their small file size), surely there are other reasons animated gifs are currently so popular. One blogger claims it’s because they are nostalgic, reminding us of the “exciting frontier culture of the Internet’s early days” where computer users were exposed to a variety of images, “the wildest, most beautiful or most depraved things that the world has to offer.” Or perhaps we’re gravitating toward animated gifs because we’re living in the age of microblogging platforms like Tumblr and Twitter in which 140 characters are all we need to get our point across; in other words, video-shorthand “seems a similarly natural response” to these networks, some maintain. Finally, another blogger points out that perhaps this current interest in moving gifs derives from a progressive shift in the creative process. Again, like early cinema, the first animated gifs featured low resolutions and choppy transitions (MobileYouth). But now, as you can see below, they’ve become a stunning art form all their own.
Enter the cinemagraph. First attributed to photographer Jamie Beck and motion graphics artist Kevin Burg, cinemagraphs “combine still photography and video to ‘unfreeze’ a photo in time.” In essence, they’re more than a picture but less than a video, and significantly, because of their gif format, they could only exist and be appreciated online. So what do you think? First, are cinemagraphs and/or animated gifs in general art? And second, why do you think we’ve reverted to the days of early cinema, staring at and enjoying silent, plotless, moving images within a relatively private setting? Are we really that desperate to simplify our hectic, media-saturated, image-filled lives?
Need More?
Beck’s and Berg’s creations are posted frequently on their Tumblr, From Me to You.
And the Tumblr If we don’t, remember me hosts some lovely cinemagraphs of famous film scenes; I’ve concluded this post with a few of my favorites below.

“A boy’s best friend is his mother.” Psycho (1960)

“Whatever I photograph, I always lose.” Peeping Tom (1960)
“My whole life is pointed in one direction. There never has been a choice for me.” Taxi Driver (1976)
“I’m a Dapper Dan man!” O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000)
“I was a ghost. I didn’t see anyone. No one saw me. I was the barber.” The Man Who Wasn’t There (2001)
















What a fascinating post, Kelli! And thanks for sharing–I love the gif of Anthony Perkins. Amazing, truly!
Thanks!
Nice post & gallery!
Another frame of reference that might resonate, especially with a generation GIFfers, is the pictures in Harry Potter. I remember when I read the first book, one of the many stand-out concepts in Rowling's wizarding world was the idea that a still image was foreign – every picture was an animated GIF! I don't know if it is a direct connection for many folks online, but being able to capture an element of a pervasive & formative fantasy world adds to the sense of play & fun that GIFs offer.
And thanks for including the Ron dancing GIF which is so dear to my heart! You might also consider the popularity of sports GIFs, which create a highlight reel snapshot of a key play or freak happening.
Of course I couldn't omit "Ron F'ing Swanson" from the list. Too good to pass up!
Re: Harry Potter, good point. I actually thought about that when @proctor tweeted me this link of Emma Watson doing the first moving cover for Marie Claire: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TzWQJnrn91w
Kinda creepy actually.
Thanks for commenting!
In the circles I tend to travel in Tumblr, gifs also seem to be really popular within fandoms. It's a great, succinct way to either comment on your object of fannish adoration (as seems to happen a lot in fan gifs around the Watson/Sherlock relationship in the new BBC series) or insert/incorporate your fandom into your reactions to non-fandom events/items (as in the ubiquity of 'Supernatural' gifs in reactions to non-'Supernatural' posts). Perhaps it's a visual equivalent to quoting lines from your favorite film/television program? They may still be funny to non-fans, but they gain added significance for other fans and create a link between fans who are potentially continents apart.
Perhaps it’s a visual equivalent to quoting lines from your favorite film/television program?
— Hmmm, interesting. Will have to think further on that one. Thanks!
Kelli,
Great post! I'm really intrigued by the GIFs towards the end of your piece. They have a certain haunting quality about them, especially the person reading the newspaper on the park bench and the cafe/taxi. I think the quote of "unfreezing time" gets to the heart of the matter. For me, these little movies exist somewhere between moving images and still photographs, or at least highlight the dialectic tension between the two. The movement is so subtle in some that I nearly missed it at first. Thus, I initially look at them as if photographs and then the movement suddenly emerges. They sort of give us life and lifelessness in the same instant. In many ways, these remind me of Bill Viola's experiments in super-slow-motion video (http://is.gd/MutwuE), which have a similar power. But I digress. Thanks for the thought-provoking post!
Yes, haunting is definitely the right word for several of those GIFs toward the end!
[...] very interesting post from Kelli Marshall on Animated GIFs and our return to early cinema. Over a hundred years on, and the same things still entrance us. Indeed, spectators of early cinema [...]
[...] very interesting post from Kelli Marshall on Animated GIFs and our return to early cinema. Over a hundred years on, and the same things still entrance us. Indeed, spectators of early cinema [...]
[...] connections, we have animated GIFs as entertainment. It was great. Animated GIFs have even staged a comeback recently. Here’s a classic [...]
[...] a strange way, still perfectly entertaining. It’s even been suggested that our more recent fascination with animated GIFs is a throwback to [...]
@FayebellineW Ooooo, you send ‘em to that one, they get a coffee-drenched Firth!
http://t.co/ZVR9ytht
[...] written about animated gifs (as a throwback to the cinema of attractions). I’ve circulated animated gifs on Tumblr. [...]
[...] my affection for Colin Firth in conjunction with my love for Gene Kelly, as an introduction to my thoughts on animated gifs and as a reason for surviving the loooong 2011 Academy Awards ceremony. But to date, I’ve not [...]
[...] Kelli. “Animated Gifs, Cinemagraphs, and Our Return to Early Cinema.” MediAcademia. 8 Jun. [...]